Freitag, 7. September 2007

I went to see...

I went to see The Lord of the Rings - the Return of the King today. It didn’t start until we had had at least a half an hour of ear-splitting commercials, which added extra strain to an already bladder-bursting experience. People could be seen in silhouette climbing over crowds and partitions throughout the last third of the film in a desperate struggle, as intense as any on the screen, to have a piss.And so to the movie itself. First the bad news: the Elfy bits with Elrond, Galadriel and Arwen are as boring as ever. Every time someone other than Sam or Gollum makes a speech longer than ”Let’s go kill the bastards”, there is much knitting of eyebrows and lowering of vocal registers and it’s all terribly sententious just like the book. A black vs white theme could be drawn from the movie but I suspect that Jackson just had hundreds of Maoris available whose exotic looks when compared to the white main cast allowed him to differentiate their looks from the men and hobbits when the orc make-up went on. This is possibly the most disturbing aspect of the three films, its potential for racist exploitation by idiots.Now the good news: the big battle is as exciting as anything ever put on screen. The acting of Elijah Wood, Sean Astin and Andy Serkin is excellent. The fantasy architecture, especially of Minas Tireth is everything for which a fan of fantasy architecture could wish. Shelob the spider is truly frightening and the climactic scenes on Mount Doom are an appropriate and thrilling climax to the story. The scenes with the oliphaunts are eye-popping.Do, however, have a whizz just before the movie starts and I would recommend that you don’t buy a soft-drink from the candy counter,The verdict on the trilogy as a whole: though it deletes a few fairly tedious bits, (Tom Bombadil and the scouring of the shire, which, while touching, is anti-climactic), the public got what it paid for, an as faithful as possible film adaptation of an epic cultural phenomenon.Like any epic, (The Bible, The Lion King) it is possible to extract dodgy supremacist messages from the story. Some people would lumber poor old Tolkein with the false philosophic burden of “Defender of European Values against the Encroaching Tainters of the Race”. Actually , with his son fighting in France, it was the encroachment of German facists and their Italian and Spanish allies that he was thinking of.A re-emerging bunch of Euro-neo facists have the usual wooly, absurd philosophic baggage which seems to be a nauseous blend of Opus Dei (renowned for its facist sympathies) and what they term archeo-futurism and plain old-fashioned racism, (we’re being infested with Chinese!). The words, as always, are slightly different but the stench remains the same. And, as ever, people of conscience are not fooled.Fans of the movies will be blissed-out.

4 Kommentare:

cswitqh427 hat gesagt…

...and fans of other movies will be happy to have more seats in the cinema to choose from for a while.:-D

newnewsex hat gesagt…

teeheehee. I enjoyed it, but afterwards, rushed off to the loo post haste!

tuciefamily17 hat gesagt…

A predicament a gentleman of my years can fully appreciate!

howhypemtensiveari72yahoocom hat gesagt…

I can see your point about a racist element in the LOTR - but it's always been my experience that anyone who is commited to being a racist will make up any excuse in order to justify his behavior.Even so, I think whats just as interesting as the story itself is the circumstances in which the story was written. The world was a different place then - I wouldn't say more innocent, just different.I read an old newspaper comic one, dated aournd 1928 or so - in it, the family prepares to go to Chinatown for dinner out. The Matriarch expresses her concern that Chinatown is a dangerous place (her young son remarks "I ain't scared of no chinks"), but the father persists, and they family go have a nice dinner. On the way home, they stop for ice cream, and it's so good that they have 3 or 4 servings each. Later, when they get home they all feel sick, and one of the parents (I forget which) says "Those damn Chinese tried to poison us!"I think it's a pretty good snapshot of the era. Even then, the idea of rascism was considered pretty ridiculous, yet it still endures. The only way of keeping it in check is to mention how remarkably simple minded racism is.Which reminds me, have you ever seen the movie "Pleasantville"? It's merely brilliant.